Theological Profile · The Four Views on the Table
Huldrych Zwingli
1484 – 1531
The reformer who stripped the altar bare, and asked the church to stop looking for Christ in the elements and start looking for him in faith.
- People's priest, Grossmünster, Zurich
- Humanist, trained under Erasmus's influence
- Quarterly communion liturgy, 1525
- Died at the Battle of Kappel, 1531
Life
A humanist who became a soldier of Christ
Of the four, the only reformer who died on a battlefield, and the only one trained as a Renaissance classicist rather than a scholastic or a monk.
Huldrych Zwingli was born January 1, 1484, in the Swiss village of Wildhaus, the son of a local magistrate. He studied at the Universities of Vienna and Basel, where he absorbed the methods of Renaissance humanism — a return to the original Greek and Hebrew texts, rather than their medieval Latin commentary — and fell under the influence of Erasmus during the older scholar's years in Basel. Ordained a priest, he served first as a parish priest in Glarus, where he accompanied Swiss mercenaries as an army chaplain, an experience that left him permanently opposed to the mercenary trade and alert to the corruptions of institutional power, whether military or ecclesiastical.
In 1519 he became the people's priest at the Grossmünster in Zurich, and immediately broke with convention by preaching straight through books of the New Testament verse by verse — lectio continua — rather than following the church's prescribed lectionary, a method he saw as putting the text itself, not church tradition, back in charge of the pulpit. Over the following years Zurich under his leadership abolished clerical celibacy, the Lenten fast, and religious images: paintings, statues, and organs were removed from the city's churches in a deliberate campaign against anything that might compete with the plain preaching of the Word for the believer's attention.
In 1525 he replaced the Latin Mass with a new vernacular communion liturgy, celebrated only four times a year rather than weekly, emphasizing thanksgiving and remembrance over any transaction at the altar. His dispute with Luther over the meaning of the Supper came to a head at the 1529 Marburg Colloquy and was never resolved. When Catholic cantons went to war against Zurich in 1531, Zwingli marched out as a field chaplain and was killed at the Battle of Kappel, one of roughly five hundred Zurich dead — the only one of the four reformers covered here to die in battle rather than in bed.
Zwingli's Latin word for the Supper was drawn deliberately from Roman military vocabulary: sacramentum originally meant a soldier's oath of allegiance. For Zwingli the meal was, in part, exactly that — a public pledge of loyalty to Christ and to the community of believers, sworn together, not a private transaction between one worshiper and the elements.
Chronology
Life and reform
- 1484
Born January 1 in Wildhaus, Switzerland.
- 1498–1506
Studies at Vienna and Basel; formed by humanist scholarship and Erasmus's influence.
- 1506
Ordained; becomes parish priest at Glarus, serving also as a mercenary chaplain.
- 1519
Becomes people's priest at the Grossmünster in Zurich; begins expository preaching straight through Scripture.
- 1522–25
Zurich abolishes clerical celibacy, Lenten fasting rules, and religious images in churches.
- 1525
Institutes a new vernacular communion liturgy, celebrated quarterly, replacing the Mass.
- 1529
The Marburg Colloquy: face-to-face dispute with Luther over the Supper ends without agreement.
- 1531
Dies October 11 as a field chaplain at the Battle of Kappel.
His central claim
To believe is to eat
Zwingli did not call the Supper empty. He called it a sign — and insisted a sign can carry real weight without containing what it signifies.
Zwingli's starting point was a conviction about Christ's body itself: it ascended, it is finite, and a finite body cannot be present in more than one place at once, no matter how the words of institution are parsed. If that is true, "this is my body" cannot mean the bread literally becomes, or literally contains, Christ's flesh. Zwingli read est ("is") in the sense scripture itself sometimes uses it elsewhere — as signifies — so that "this is my body" means "this represents my body," in the way Christ elsewhere says "I am the vine" or "I am the door" without anyone taking it as a claim about his literal shape.
This did not make the Supper nothing, in his own account. To his king and his critics alike he insisted: "We believe that Christ is truly present in the Lord's Supper; yea, we believe that there is no communion without the presence of Christ." But the presence he meant was not oral or bodily — it was the presence Christ grants to faith itself, received "in a sacramental and spiritual manner by the religious, believing, and pious heart." His famous formula compresses the whole position into four words: to believe is to eat. The mouth receives bread; the soul, if it has faith already at work in it, receives Christ — not because the bread delivers him, but because the Spirit who gave the believer faith is the same Spirit at work in the room.
Against Luther's insistence that Christ's body is objectively present "in, with, and under" the elements whether or not anyone believes, Zwingli pressed a theological, not merely a physical, objection: "The bodily presence of Christ could not produce faith, as faith is from God, for those whom God has chosen." Faith cannot be caused by eating; it is caused only by God. Making the sacrament itself the vehicle of grace, for Zwingli, risked relocating the Spirit's sovereign work into a transaction any mouth could perform, worthy or not — precisely the "magic" he believed both Rome and Luther, in their different ways, still had not fully escaped.
"That his body is literally eaten is far from the truth and the nature of faith."
The flashpoint
The colloquy he wanted and Luther didn't
Zwingli went to Marburg hoping for a united Protestant front. He left having failed to get it from the one reformer whose respect he most wanted.
Of the two men at Marburg in October 1529, it was Zwingli who arrived eager for reconciliation, having traveled further and at greater personal risk to be there. Accounts of the colloquy describe him pressing Luther again and again on the physics of the claim: how can a body in one place, seated at the Father's right hand, also be substantially present on every altar in Christendom at the same hour? Luther's answer was to refuse the terms of the question — God's power is not bound by what is physically imaginable to us — and, according to a frequently repeated account of the meeting, to keep returning to the words he had chalked on the table in front of him: Hoc est corpus meum.
Fourteen of fifteen articles were agreed before the colloquy ended — a substantial, often-overlooked body of shared Protestant conviction. The fifteenth recorded their failure plainly. Later tradition remembers Zwingli as visibly moved, even brought to tears, by the prospect of parting from fellow reformers he considered brothers in the same cause against Rome. Luther was not similarly moved: refusing to extend the hand of Christian fellowship at the colloquy's close, and, after Zwingli's death in battle two years later, pronouncing that he had died "in great sin and blasphemy." The breach opened at Marburg has outlived both of them, visible today in the different wording different traditions still use at the Table.
Selected bibliography
The Zurich reforms in print
On the Supper
- Commentary on True and False Religion1525
- On the Lord's Supper1526
- Friendly Exegesis (reply to Luther)1527
- Fidei Ratio (confession to Emperor Charles V)1530
- Account of the Faith (confession to King Francis I)1531
Zurich Reform
- The Sixty-seven Articles1523
- New vernacular communion liturgy1525
In his own words
Quotation library
Filter by theme.
Provenance
Sources consulted
Verify any quotation against the primary text before it goes into teaching material.